Sign In

Jamaican Restaurants in Brooklyn — IslandVibes.nyc
Caribbean NYC Guide

Jamaican Restaurants in Brooklyn

Brooklyn is the Jamaican capital — Flatbush, Crown Heights, Bed-Stuy

You already know Brooklyn is the heartbeat of Caribbean culture in NYC, and when it comes to Jamaican food, we're talking about the real deal. From the bustling corners of Flatbush to the soul of Crown Heights and Bed-Stuy, these neighborhoods serve up everything from flaky beef patties that'll transport you straight to Kingston to curry goat that your Jamaican auntie would approve of. This is where Golden Krust started before going nationwide, where Allan's Bakery has been feeding families for decades, and where spots like Buff Patty and The Islands keep the tradition alive with that perfect blend of authenticity and Brooklyn swagger.

We update this list every week because these family-run spots change their hours like the weather, and trust us, you don't want to show up for oxtail on a Tuesday only to find out it's a Wednesday-Sunday thing. Give them a call before you roll through – most of these places are small operations where the owners are also the cooks, and sometimes they sell out of the good stuff early or close up when family business calls.

1

The Islands

📍 803 Washington Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238
📞 (718) 398-3575

A Bed-Stuy neighborhood restaurant serving reliable Jamaican comfort food. Their stew chicken with rice and peas is a lunchtime favorite, and the breakfast plate with ackee, saltfish, and fried dumplings…

See listing →
2

Labay Market & Grill

📍 9122 Flatlands Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11236
📞 (718) 272-3800

Canarsie's go-to spot for authentic Jamaican food. Labay serves daily specials from the steam table — oxtail on Sundays, brown stew fish on Fridays, and curry goat any day you're…

See listing →
3

Allan’s Bakery

📍 1109 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225
📞 (718) 774-7892

A beloved Caribbean bakery on Nostrand Ave famous for their rum cake, hard dough bread, bun and cheese, and fresh-baked Jamaican patties. Allan's has been a Brooklyn institution for over…

See listing →
4

Golden Krust Caribbean Bakery & Grill

📍 1381 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11210
📞 (718) 859-4360

The original Golden Krust on Flatbush Ave — an iconic Brooklyn institution serving Jamaican beef patties, jerk chicken, oxtail, and fresh-baked coco bread since the 1990s. A must-visit for authentic…

See listing →
5

Buff Patty

📍 1402 Utica Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11203
📞 (718) 451-2500

Home of the craveable Jamaican beef patty and coco bread combo. Buff Patty on Utica Ave serves freshly baked patties — beef, chicken, veggie — alongside full Jamaican lunch plates…

See listing →
6

De Hot Pot Restaurant

📍 1127 Washington Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225
📞 (718) 856-3644

De Hot Pot brings authentic yard-style Jamaican cooking to Flatbush with their legendary steam table that's been satisfying the community for years. Known for their rich, slow-cooked stewed peas with…

See listing →

Own a spot on this list?

Claim your listing free. Or upgrade to Featured ($29/mo) for top placement and 3× the clicks.

See pricing Claim free