Sign In

Caribbean Restaurants in Harlem — IslandVibes.nyc
Caribbean NYC Guide

Caribbean Restaurants in Harlem

Harlem Caribbean — 125th + 145th + Washington Heights

When you think Harlem and Caribbean food, you're talking about generations of flavor that built this neighborhood into what it is today. From the Dominican spots on 181st to the Puerto Rican counters serving up perfect pernil, this stretch of uptown Manhattan holds some of the realest Caribbean eats in the city. Whether you're craving mofongo at 2am or hunting down the best alcapurrias north of the Bronx, Harlem's got you covered with family recipes that haven't changed in decades.

Before you roll up to any of these spots, give them a call first – hours can shift and some of our favorite places are still figuring out their post-pandemic rhythm. We update this list every week because places open, close, and change faster than the 6 train, so bookmark this page and check back. These aren't tourist traps – they're neighborhood joints where abuelas still run the kitchen and regulars know to order in Spanish for the best plates.

1

Miss Lily’s

📍 2067 Frederick Douglass Blvd, New York, NY 10026
📞 (212) 913-9700

Vibrant Jamaican restaurant bringing island culture to Harlem with colorful decor, dancehall music, and a menu featuring jerk chicken, escovitch fish, and rum cocktails. The brunch is legendary and the…

See listing →
2

La Fonda Boricua

📍 169 E 106th St, New York, NY 10029
📞 (212) 410-7292

East Harlem's beloved Puerto Rican restaurant serving traditional Boricua cuisine in a colorful, cultural setting. Their pernil, mofongo, and arroz con gandules are made with love and tradition. Live salsa…

See listing →
3

El Nuevo Caridad

📍 2389 Broadway, New York, NY 10024
📞 (212) 874-2780

Dominican-Chinese restaurant serving the iconic NYC combo of arroz con pollo and lo mein. This Upper West Side spot embodies the unique Dominican-Chinese dining culture that's been a New York…

See listing →
4

Malecon Restaurant

📍 4141 Broadway, New York, NY 10033
📞 (212) 927-3812

A Washington Heights institution serving Dominican home cooking 24 hours a day. Malecon is famous for their rotisserie chicken, pernil, and mangu breakfast. The whole roasted chicken with tostones and…

See listing →
5

El Barrio’s Cuchifrito

📍 168 E 116th St, New York, NY 10029
📞 (212) 410-2200

A legendary East Harlem cuchifrito shop serving fried Puerto Rican street food — alcapurrias, bacalaitos, rellenos de papa, and pastelillos. This is old-school Boricua food culture at its most authentic.…

See listing →

Own a spot on this list?

Claim your listing free. Or upgrade to Featured ($29/mo) for top placement and 3× the clicks.

See pricing Claim free