Sign In

Best Oxtail in NYC — IslandVibes.nyc
Caribbean NYC Guide

Best Oxtail in NYC

Slow-braised, brown gravy, butter-soft — the oxtail map

1

Negril Village

📍 70 W 3rd St, New York, NY 10012
📞 (212) 477-2804

Upscale Jamaican restaurant in Greenwich Village — the first Caribbean fine-dining room to plant a flag downtown. Elevated takes on jerk, oxtail, curry, and a serious rum bar. A destination…

See listing →
2

Labay Market & Grill

📍 9122 Flatlands Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11236
📞 (718) 272-3800

Canarsie's go-to spot for authentic Jamaican food. Labay serves daily specials from the steam table — oxtail on Sundays, brown stew fish on Fridays, and curry goat any day you're…

See listing →
3

Feeding Tree

📍 892 Gerard Ave, Bronx, NY 10452
📞 (718) 293-5025

A Bronx landmark for Jamaican food near Yankee Stadium. Feeding Tree has been serving massive portions of jerk chicken, curry goat, and oxtail to hungry fans and locals for years.…

See listing →
4

Golden Krust Caribbean Bakery & Grill

📍 1381 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11210
📞 (718) 859-4360

The original Golden Krust on Flatbush Ave — an iconic Brooklyn institution serving Jamaican beef patties, jerk chicken, oxtail, and fresh-baked coco bread since the 1990s. A must-visit for authentic…

See listing →
5

Jam-Rock Cuisine

📍 3670 White Plains Rd, Bronx, NY 10467
📞 (347) 202-9356

Family-owned Jamaican spot in Williamsbridge. Oxtail, curry goat, brown stew chicken, ackee and saltfish — and a steady weekend crowd. Online ordering and delivery.

See listing →
6

Best Bites Caribbean

📍 4601 Church Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11203
📞 (718) 462-3842

East Flatbush mainstay where the steam table is the menu: oxtail and butter beans, brown stew chicken, curry goat, jerk chicken, stew fish on Fridays, plus rice and peas, mac…

See listing →
7

Caribbean Vibes Restaurant

📍 1436 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11226
📞 (347) 663-9085

Flatbush counter-service spot known for oxtail, curry goat, and generous portions. Real deal Jamaican.

See listing →
8

Pattie Hut

📍 543 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11216
📞 (718) 622-3222

Pattie Hut is the Bed-Stuy Jamaican counter for stewed chicken, oxtail, curry goat, and jerk — alongside the beef and chicken patties that give the place its name. A Nostrand…

See listing →

Own a spot on this list?

Claim your listing free. Or upgrade to Featured ($29/mo) for top placement and 3× the clicks.

See pricing Claim free