Sign In

Best Oxtail in NYC — IslandVibes.nyc
Caribbean NYC Guide

Best Oxtail in NYC

Slow-braised, brown gravy, butter-soft — the oxtail map

1

Footprints Cafe

📍 5814 Clarendon Rd, Brooklyn, NY 11203
📞 (718) 451-3181

Long-running Flatbush Jamaican cafe and fine-dining restaurant. Known for curry goat, oxtail, stewed chicken, and a proper Sunday brunch. Multi-generation Brooklyn institution.

See listing →
2

Best Bites Caribbean

📍 4601 Church Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11203
📞 (718) 462-3842

East Flatbush mainstay where the steam table is the menu: oxtail and butter beans, brown stew chicken, curry goat, jerk chicken, stew fish on Fridays, plus rice and peas, mac…

See listing →
3

Golden Krust Caribbean Bakery & Grill

📍 1381 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11210
📞 (718) 859-4360

The original Golden Krust on Flatbush Ave — an iconic Brooklyn institution serving Jamaican beef patties, jerk chicken, oxtail, and fresh-baked coco bread since the 1990s. A must-visit for authentic…

See listing →
4

La’Mode BK

📍 1401 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11216
📞 (718) 316-9100

A Crown Heights restaurant and lounge from a Vincentian-led team, plating Caribbean–Asian fusion — escovitch fish bites, jerk chicken tacos, oxtail pasta — alongside sushi rolls and Korean-style wings. Happy…

See listing →
5

Pattie Hut

📍 543 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11216
📞 (718) 622-3222

Pattie Hut is the Bed-Stuy Jamaican counter for stewed chicken, oxtail, curry goat, and jerk — alongside the beef and chicken patties that give the place its name. A Nostrand…

See listing →
6

Scotch Bonnet

📍 200 Baychester Ave, Unit 81, Bronx, NY 10475
📞 (347) 924-7464

Bronx Jamaican staple on Boston Road — jerk chicken, oxtail, curry goat, patties. One of the anchors of the Bronx Caribbean food scene, serving the Wakefield and Williamsbridge communities for…

See listing →
7

Jamaica Breeze Restaurant

📍 232-02 Merrick Blvd, Laurelton, NY 11413
📞 (347) 894-8049

Pay-by-the-pound Jamaican buffet on Merrick Blvd. Oxtail, jerk chicken, ackee and saltfish, callaloo, curry chicken — full hot table, lively room, regulars who refill plates without blinking.

See listing →
8

Ranch Caribbean Vybez

📍 129 Dreiser Loop, Bronx, NY 10475
📞 (718) 484-1100

Modern sit-down Jamaican spot inside Co-op City's Dreiser Loop. Full bar, weekend brunch, jerk pasta, oxtail rice bowls — a step up from the takeout-window standard, with a 4.4 Yelp…

See listing →

Own a spot on this list?

Claim your listing free. Or upgrade to Featured ($29/mo) for top placement and 3× the clicks.

See pricing Claim free